Here’s the question of the day: are corporate stock buybacks fueling the stock market?
Let’s look at a couple of charts and a news report to help determine the answer.
Quarterly Stock Buybacks
Stock buybacks are at a nine-quarter low according to an Email TrimTabs press announcement:
“Buybacks have been trending lower for the past two years, which is a cautionary longer-term signal for U.S. equities,” said Winston Chua, analyst at TrimTabs. “Along with central bank asset purchases, buybacks have been a key pillar of support for the bull market.”
“The U.S. stock market isn’t likely to get as much of a boost from buybacks as it did in recent years,” noted Chua. “Apart from big tech firms and the too-big-to-fails, fewer companies seem willing to use lots of cash to support share prices.”
There are numerous references to that announcement, but until now, nobody checked to see if the relationship was in fact true.
S&P 500 vs. Volume Lows in Share Buybacks
If there is a relationship, I fail to see what it is, at least by looking at the chart.
That does not mean there is no relationship. Rather, it does not show up.
Logic would dictate that share buybacks lower P/E ratios thereby boosting earnings, making stocks look more reasonably priced.
But if reasonable P/E logic was in play, P/E’s would not be as ridiculous as they are. Then again, Wall Street charlatans point buybacks and forward P/Es as evidence the stock market is cheap.
- Stock buybacks are still sufficient to fuel the stock market
- Something else is happening, such as another Fed-sponsored mania
#2 is a given. #1 certainly doesn’t hurt. But market sentiment is so strong now, stock buybacks just may not matter much at all.
When stock market sentiment turns, I strongly suspect buyback announcements will be meaningless.