Bob Hoye: Sensational is The New Normal

Posted by Bob Hoye - Institutional Advisors

Share on Facebook

Tweet on Twitter


UnknownSigns of The Times

Obviously, the rich harvest of headlines continues. It is worth adding that they only occur with the culmination of great financial manias. The problem is that each soaring bull market, sensational has become the norm. Stock pickers think that certain stocks and their ability to discover them are unassailable. On Business News Network, there was a fund manager boasting that while the Hang Seng index was down 20% his picks in Hong Kong were unchanged. The notion that outstanding management and the genius of the Fed are proof against major setbacks is so 1929.

It has been convenient for interventionist economics to assume that the central bank is the perfect instrument for imposing policy. In the early 1930s, most understood that the abilities of the Fed were overwhelmed by the fury of the crash. Most also understood that the boom caused the bust, which prompted the passing of the SEC and Glass-Steagall Acts. These were designed to prevent another bubble. So that there would never be another crash.

If one reviews the newspapers of the day one would read that when the Fed raised the discount rate to 6% in August 1929 it intended to tighten funds to Wall Street, but also intended to ease funds for Main Street. In the crash the NY Fed bought bonds out of the market to inject liquidity. It exceeded its authority by a factor of six. Early in 1930, a Fed official noted that they had met the crisis in the usual way by discounting liberally.

In the 1960s, as econometrics and computers ascended, intrusive economists needed the policy instrument to be perfect. Thus the argument that the guys at the Fed were deliberately tight and that caused the Great Depression.

How naïve.

Thanks to the permanency of the internet record, all of the reckless extension of Fed credit can never be buried. And now with the massive efforts made by Chinese policymakers so well publicized, the record of this massive failure will be permanently visible.

The 2007 Bubble and Crash generated some despicable policy utterances. One was that in December 2007 the establishment boasted that nothing could go wrong. The Fed had a “dream team” of economists. A crash was impossible and only two years later they were boasting that without the Fed’s magnificent efforts the crash would not have ended.

China’s recent contributions to official folly would include the following:

If in April, China had approved only 10 IPOs would the rally would have continued?

Policy intrusions, no matter how well rationalized, are mainly nonsense.

Our determinants for the peak in the SSEC needed another set of Upside Capitulations, hopefully accomplished in June ().


Last week, we observed that the main commodity sectors, such as base metals and grains, were oversold. We wondered about the possibility of another “rotation” and decided against it.

Some commodities were oversold, but deterioration in the credit markets was getting concerning.

The key item this week is crude oil dropping to new lows and while getting oversold, in this market normal oversold may have little influence. Instead, we should look at recent seasonal forces. Over the past 15 years, there has been a tendency for crude to set serious lows in December to January.

Much the same holds for the gasoline contract.

Our view from last year remains and that is the popular notion that falling petroleum prices would help the consumers’ gas tank was not the issue. The issue was commodity price deflation.

And generally commodities remain weak, driving the DBC down to 15, which takes out the low of 16.71 set in April. All the “rotations” out of last December have been wiped out.

The cyclical peak was 32 set in April 2011, and the peak in 2008 was 45.

One of the features of the typical post-bubble condition is weakening commodities. Today’s pop to 15.18 seems tied to the setback in the DX. A relief rally that could be brief.

Lines in the Sand

In looking at the concerning issues over the weekend, on Monday the “Lines In The Sand” list was put together, as in “Hey!” through this level would mark a failure.

The most persuasive one would be the breakout on spread widening. Yesterday’s number was 220 bps, which is more than the breakout, it is becoming dramatic.

The next one would be the NYSE A/Ds taking out the last low. This was accomplished this morning. The decline is now longer than the one that completed last October. The chart follows.

Another would be the SPX taking out the 200-Day ma, which would be Step Two. Today is working on a big bar down, all of it below the key moving average.

Complacency has had remarkable popularity and showing change, the VIX has jumped from 10.88 to 17. Getting above the July high of 20 would formally end complacency.

On our Friends of The Bull Market, last week’s advice was that their shelf-life and guidance had expired.

Bob Hoye is the chief financial strategist of Institutional Advisers
08/28/15  article by Bob Hoye – Widows and Oprhans Sell