Michael Campbell: With all the gyrations, confusion and negative bias up until very recently Don, was that just part your buy when it snows and sell when it goes strategy?
Don Vialoux: It certainly was and given the whole idea is that you buy when it snows there actually is a forecast for snow in Northern Ontario today. Tells you that now is the time of year to reconsider getting back into the market. In fact we had a very important inflection point in both US and Canadian equity markets on October the 4th that was the start of the period of seasonal strengths for this year and that implies that now is good time to be in a equity markets with some qualifications.
Michael: Lets get those qualifications out right now.
Don: Since October the 4th we have seen the TSE composite index go up 11. 4%. We see the NASDAQ composite index go up 16.0% and those moves are all within less than two weeks. An amazing recovery for equity markets, we were oversold on October the 4th and now quickly we have become overbought short term. The qualification is we should be buyers of Canadian and US equities and ETFs on any kind of weakness between now and the traditional entry period of October 28th.
Michael: Buy dips?
Don: Very much so. To put in perspective looking at the percentage of stocks of the S&P 500 that were above the 50 day moving average. Two weeks ago 20% of S&P 500 stocks were above their 50 day moving average, as of last night it’s 80%! That’s very clearly an overbought level implying that we should look for a bit of correction between now and the next couple of weeks.
We are just entering the big third quarter earnings report periodand theser earnings reports are not going to be nice. They are going to be significantly lower in many cases than many analyst’s had expected. These earnings reports could cause a dip in the market.
Once the earnings reports are out of the way, its off to races to the upside until at least January 2012.
Michael: Your methodology is seasonality ,which is looking at tendencies in different seasons of the year as the indicator for getting in or out of the market. Is it really that simple?
Don: It really is that simple. There are certain sectors in markets that move higher at certain times of the year based on annual recurring events. I mentioned October 28th based on historical data over the last 60 years is on average a day that you want to move into equity markets in North America. Then you have to fine tune that date each year using technical analysis, looking for momentum indicators that tell you if the markets are oversold right around that time. It’s usually October 28th plus or minus about three weeks and we actually got an oversold market on October the 4th here in 2011. Momentum indicators had turned positive so we started to re-enter the market in our Horizons AlphaPro Seasonal Rotation ETF at that time.
Michael: What key factors this year told you that the turning point would be to October 4th instead of the average of October 28th?
Don: It is so important to be very disciplined to take this approach. We looked for momentum indicators to be oversold right around this time of year. The particular momentum indicators we look at are stochastics, specifically when they are below 20% and moving towards exceeding that level. We look for the RSI, the Relative Strength Index being 30% and moving higher above that level. We are also looking at moving average convergence, an oversold level thats giving you a positive crossover. Now these things don’t always happen exactly, but generally speaking they do happen at major bottoms in the market and we had a number of those signals actually occur shortly after October the 4th.
Michael: Do you have a checklist and as they are checked off its starts to tell you the direction has changed?
Don: It’s so important that you combine the technical’s, the fundamentals, annual recurring events and seasonality. When they all come together that’s when you do a trade.
Traditionally equity markets move higher between now and around the first or second of January and that has a lot to do with how people are perceiving markets at this time of year. We’re getting into the Christmas period, people are in happier mood thinking about Christmas, buying gifts, consumer electronic goods (like the huge lineups for iPhone 4S‘s) and markets want to go higher on all this good news. It’s also the fourth quarter earnings report period and companies just love to give you good news with those fourth quarter results since they’re just prior to release of their annual result. Bottom line is a positive period of anticipation going into early January of each year.
Michael: How would your seasonal, technical and cyclical indicators be affected if a big piece of fundamental news occurred, for example if Greece fell off the edge of a cliff right in the middle of a predicted seasonal turn?
Don: There is no question that macro events do have an impact on markets and we’ve had a lot of macro events during the last three or four weeks. What it’s done is created a huge amount of volatility in the equity markets, much higher than average. As long as these macro events continue, as we expect they will over the next few weeks, there will be continued very high volatility in the equity markets.
Michael: In early August you were looking for lows in gold stocks somewhere in the August, September time frame. What do you see now?
Don: The sectors, which do very well between now and the end of the year, tend to be technology, consumer discretionary, industrials and agriculture. Gold and silver are very fascinating. Normally gold and silver start moving higher right around the beginning of July, as they did this year, hen they tend to strengthen right through until the third week of September. Normally after that they go into a brief correction into the month of October, but this year is the seasonality peaked out sooner than expected. It actually peaked out around the second week in September, instead of near the end of the September. So we had a technical sell signals on gold, silver and precious metals stocks at that point in time so we took some really nice profits in our fund. But this is also telling me something else. It means that the period of seasonal weakness which you normally get into month of October is not happening this year. The seasonality has all been pushed forward or backwards by approximately one month, and we actually had some technical buy signals on both gold and silver as well as precious metal equities during the last two weeks.
Since 2003 the classic time to buy gold is when it touches it’s 200 day moving average, and it got all the way down to that level( $1,535) two weeks ago. It was a classic opportunity to buy gold at that time. If you look now gold it is at $1,681, that’s a huge move and it happened very quickly. Clearly for gold the next period of seasonal strength goes from now right through until the end of February so we have lots of room and lots ofd time on the upside for both gold and for silver. Also silver normally outperforms gold during this October to February period so I suggest you may want to focus on the silver sector as opposed to gold.
Michael: How has your Horizons AlphaPro Seasonal Rotation ETF performed this year?
Don: We are up to 25% since we launched this fund 22 months ago, and the net asset value of the fund hit an all time high yesterday. Our seasonal fund is showing better than average returns in the markets and it’s also showing less volatility than most other funds as well.
Michael: What sectors/industries besides silver and gold are you looking to buy on dips right now?
Don: We’ve actually gone back into the agriculture sector during the last ten days or so. Here is the story; agriculture normally does very well from the beginning of July right through until the end of the year, but the real sweet spot for agriculture is actually from the beginning of October right through until the end of December. A lot of that has to do with grain prices. This time of year grain prices start moving higher like agriculture generally from the beginning of October right through until the end of December. If you want to get a feel for what’s happening there is a ETF which actually tracks the top three grains, the symbol is JJG. That particular ETF bottomed about ten days ago (October 5th) and started moving higher. That’s a classic tipping indication of what’s going too happen with the agriculture stocks in general. They have already had a pretty huge move in the last ten days again so that’s the opportunity too buy the sector, if you can, on weakness, on dips over the next few weeks.
The key is to be on top of these things at all times. A classic example, the agriculture ETF that people look at in Canada is the symbol is COW, and the US it’s MOO. MOO during the last ten days is up 21.5% from it’s low on October the 4th. That’s a huge move so do you want to buy at these prices? Probably not, but you could get up to a 50% correction in MOO that would provide another opportunity to get into the sector. One of the things to watch when you’re going into these seasonal trades? You don’t only want to be in a sector which is has good seasonality, you also want to be into sectors which are outperforming the market. As long as the sector is outperforming the market you stick with the seasonal trade.
Michael: Can you explain the simple technical rule of thumb, the 50% rule?
Don: Yes something which one of your guests previously, Dennis Gartman mentions quiet frequently. Often a security will go back to what he calls the box. The box is a retracement of between 40% and 60% of a previous move. Lets say a stock goes from $10 to $20, or a $10 move. If you get a correction of 40% of that $10 move fyou will see the price at $16 or the top of the box. If you get a 50% correction of that $10 move it will be $15 or you will be in the box. That’s the time to buy it.
Michael: Is there any tech or consumer tech that you are looking at in this period?
Don: Yes we like technology in general because this is a time when people are buying consumer electronic goods for Christmas. We also do something else, we not only buy the technology sector in general but we look at sectors in the technology sector that are outperforming. One of those outperforming subsectors is the semiconductor sector which is out performing technology. So we made the choice of buying into the semiconductor as well as the technology sector.
Michael: When you were investing in the technology sector are you looking for an exchange traded fund or are you picking specific stocks?
Don: Great question, first of all we look at the sector, and then we look at the subsector, it could be semiconductors, it could be internet, it could be software. Then we choose only the subsector which is outperforming. Then we look at the individual stocks that are part of that subsector and we invest into the individual securities. The key is to watch the performance of these securities over time, for example as soon as an individual security starts to underperform the subsector, it’s gone. As soon as the subsector underperforms the sector its gone. The key is to always be in securities or sector that’s outperforming the market.
Michael: What is your outlook on oil?
Don: Historically oil doesn’t do that well at this time of the year. Historically, the best time to be in the oil stocks and the energy stocks in general is from the end of January right through until May. It doesn’t necessarily mean that the sector will not do well, it just means that it probably will underperform the markets between now and January. So, we don’t have a focus on the energy sector at this time.
Michael: With all these titanic events going on in Europe, China, Canada and the USA, what is the currency play in all of this?
Don: C urrencies don’t have an impact on our fund because we hedge everything. We are not experts on currencies and don’t even try to be. Why take a chance? It’s been interesting to watch how currencies have been acting. The Canadian dollar actually has very strong seasonality and you can sometimes incorporate this into your investment strategy. Historically, the Canadian dollar is strongest from March to May of each year and it is weakest from October to December each year. Right now is a weak period of time for the Canadian dollar and I think the Canadian dollar hit a very important low about 10 days ago and recently has been recovering. It’s come all the way back to an important resistance level which implies that the recent bounce we’ve seen over the last 10 days is probably not going to go much further.
Michael: It’s uch a fascinating way you work through things and people can get more on that with www.timingthemarket.ca and also Don and his son Jon’s EquityClock.com. Don has been a regular guest on Money Talks, also key note speaker at Money Talks World Outlook Conference with his fascinating interpretation of markets, the clarity of his methodology and his discipline.
Fascinating as usual Don, I appreciate your finding time to speak with us this weekend.
Don Vialoux
Equity Clock is a division of the Tech Talk Financial Network, a market analysis company that provides technical, fundamental and seasonality analysis on a daily basis via TimingTheMarkets.com and EquityClock.com. Equity Clock’s mission is to identify periods of reoccurring strength among individual equities in the market using methodologies presented by some of the top analysts in the industry, including that of Don Vialoux, author of TimingTheMarkets.com.
Don has 37 years of experience in the Investment Industry. He is a past president of the Canadian Society of Technical Analysts (www.csta.org) and a former technical analyst at RBC Investments. Don earned his Chartered Market Technician (CMT) designation from the Market Technician Association in 1995. His CMT paper entitled “Seasonality in Canadian Equity Markets” was published in the Spring-Summer 1996 edition of the MTA Journal. Don also has extensive experience with Exchange Traded Funds (also know as Index Participation Units) as well as conservative option strategies. In 1990 he wrote a report that was released in the International Federation of Technical Analyst Journal entitled “Profiting from a Combination of Technical and Fundamental Analysis”. The report introduced ” The Eight Phases of the Stock Market Cycle”, an investment concept that continues to identify profitable entry and exit points for North American equity markets. He is currently a member of the Toronto Society of Fundamental Analyst’s Derivatives Committee. Now he is the author of a daily letter on equity markets available free on the internet. The reports can be accessed daily right here at www.dvtechtalk.com.